“What is your bank trying to sneak by you?” appeared in bold letters on my computer screen. The screen was then filled with the complex and confusing words we’ve all seen in small print documents communicating our banks’ fees and financial charge practices. I hate those documents, don’t you? In one of the cleverest business model innovations of the year, GMAC Financial Services, a $180 billion global financial institution built initially upon the General Motors’ brand, has renamed its bank as Ally Bank and redefined its value promise. Like a river seeking lower ground, Ally Bank moved right into the heart of our frustrations and forced compromises with the banking industry, offering a solution that we’ve been waiting for – a bank that’s on our side. Ally Bank’s value promise is relevant, compelling and differentiated: Bank with us and you’ll keep more of…
Value Promise and Profit Potential, Part Two
If you need a differentiated, superior value promise to win customers’ votes, how do you know when your value promise is no longer working and business model innovation is called for? Make sure you measure repeat purchases, your consideration rates and your win rates. Discover where you’re losing business and why you’re losing business, as losses signal a weakening value promise and threats to profit potential. Lost order autopsies can reveal – Nascent industries reducing customer interest in your categories Your differentiators becoming standards to be considered Non-traditional competitors entering your space Subgroups of customers exiting for simpler offerings Reduced profit margins also indicate a weakened or less differentiated value promise. But leaders too often forget that a compelling value promise creates the best context for reliable profit potential. They fix profits by cutting costs, forgetting value promise implications. A vital strategic leadership…
Value Promise and Profit Potential, Part One
Image via Wikipedia All customers buy on perceived value. Unfortunately, Walmart’s advertising has led us to define value as lowest price. We’ve forgotten that there are value promises beyond lowest price in today’s recession. Value is a mental scale with benefits on one side and costs on the other. Both sides contain tangible and intangible, emotional, functional and/or social factors. More benefits, more value, a formula Target exploited and Sears forgot. We stay in business if the customer exchange (benefits for price customers pay) is consistently profitable for us or, if we’re a venture-financed start up, promises profitability. Value promise and profit potential are interrelated. Understanding this interrelationship explains how to win. Way #1. Build the lowest cost structure for delivering required benefits. Your higher margins can be channeled back into the business to create further advantage. McDonalds dominates Wendy’s. Way #2. Offer…
Commoditization Rules, Even Before the 2008 Recession
Image via Wikipedia Commoditization – Why You Need a New Business Model Strategy In response to price pressures leaders have cut (and cut and cut) costs by outsourcing, off- shoring, consolidating, etc. Marketing departments have branded around compelling emotions expressed in powerful messaging. They’ve enhanced marketing communications to the point that potential listeners are tuning out and creating their own messages. Companies have also invested fortunes in new product development. We have three times the number of brands in our grocery stores than we had twenty years ago — I know because I live in Norway part of every month and I miss rows and rows of choice. What conference agenda or its promotional material doesn’t contain the multiple mentions of “innovation”? Our efforts aren’t working. Even before today’s daunting downturn, brand loyalty and premiums were dropping while bankruptcies and industry consolidations were…